Ethnic Studies (Participation)

After watching this discussion and reading the article, what do you think the purpose of ethnic studies is?  What assumptions do people make about ethnic studies course?  Why do you think there is a backlash against these programs and course?

Why Ethnic Studies Courses Are Good for White Kids Too

by Dr. Emery Petchauer, January 9, 2012

Last week, Judge Lewis Kowal of Arizona upheld a ban on ethnic studies classes in the Tucson Unified School District. Ethnic studies generally refer to courses such as African-American studies, Asian studies, or — in the case of the Tucson Unified School District — Mexican-American studies. Courses such as these, which comprise full programs at many public universities across the United States, often focus on the contributions that such groups have made to the world and their unique social experiences. As many of these groups have experienced different types of systematic oppression, too, these courses also take a “critical” bend and focus on power, oppression, and empowerment in society.

The controversy over ethnic studies in Arizona garnered national attention in the summer of 2010 when Gov. Jan Brewer and then-State superintendent of education Tom Horne ordered that the Mexican-American studies program in Tucson be terminated. The logic of ethnic studies opponents and the recent ruling includes the following points:

1. The courses teach students to be bitter toward and resent Whites (Side note: Does studying the American Revolution teach Whites to be bitter toward the British?).

2. The courses treat students as a collective group rather than as individuals (Side note: Does the U.S. Census make people identify as individuals or as groups?).

3. The courses teach material from a biased perspective (Side note: Is the “American Revolution” taught from identical perspectives in the United States, and, say, the UK?).

4. The courses teach students to overthrow the government (Side note: Does reading Animal Farm teach students to overthrow the government?).

Each of these points is categorically false and (as my side notes suggest) tremendously narrow-sighted. Simply put, we don’t apply this kind of thinking to other parts of school curricula. These points and others have been clearly addressed before, such as here. Consequently, I will not rehash them. Instead, I want to address a key assumption about ethnic studies classes: that they are only for students of color. This is an assumption that undergirds many misled perspectives, including the recent ones in Arizona. (Side note: Are classical philosophy classes only for Greeks?) Without a doubt, classes that focus on the contributions, experiences, and unique perspectives of so-called minority groups are indeed beneficial to students of these same groups. But, ethnic studies are good for White kids, too. Here are three reasons why:

Thinking Critically. I often say that every way of seeing also is a way of not seeing. Ethnic studies courses implicitly operate upon this maxim by illustrating how different groups in the United States and around the world often have very different perspectives on events, people and eras — both big and small. Of course, some perspectives contradict with one another and are irreconcilable. When White students (or all students for that matter) are exposed to different and even contradictory perspectives, it teaches skills such as perspective-taking, abstraction and evidence-based argumentation. These are some of the basic components of critical thinking skills that are infused within state learning standards across the nation.

For people primarily concerned with traditional school outcomes, these critical thinking skills are positively linked to school and academic performance. The wide body of empirical research on conflict resolution education programs illustrates this clearly. Conflict resolution education programs (not to be confused simply with conflict resolution), such as those pioneered by Dr. Tricia Jones of Temple University, typically produce academic improvements in schools. And, this is not necessarily because schools may be safer. A byproduct of conflict resolution education is that students learn how to think in more complex, critical and sophisticated ways. These habits of mind translate into higher performance on academic measurements. The same can follow from ethnic studies. Thinking critically is not bound to one classroom. Learning it through an ethnic studies class can then transfer over into other classes, even for White students.

Replacing White Guilt. One of the sly accusations against ethnic studies is that courses make White students feel guilty and bad about themselves. Without a doubt, some White folks feel an abstract sense of guilt when they learn about some of the atrocities that White folks have inflicted upon people of color by action and inaction. Guilt is seldom a healthy place from which to act, so this feeling is certainly not productive. Ethnic studies courses — when working well — do not produce this abstract and unproductive sense of guilt. Instead, they teach White folks how to be critical allies in specific ways to struggles for equality. Stated another way, the opposite of Whiteness is not feeling guilty about being White; it’s not Blackness, and it’s not hip-hop either. The opposite of Whiteness is pushing against oppression, inequality and White privileges. And when White folks are doing those things, they are too busy to be burdened by a much played-out sense of guilt. As ethnic studies courses outline how people of color have successfully fought for their own education, liberation and humanity, this is a vital starting point for White folks to eventually join this important work and get in where they fit in.

Functioning in Today’s World. It has long been a statistical likelihood that White folks will be a demographic minority in the United States during the lifespan of current school-age children. Though many cities and rural areas still remain deeply segregated by race, the nature of the globalized economy and workforce means that the top leaders of U.S. industries will be working alongside people who do not check the same demographic boxes or hold the same social assumptions as they do. This global reality gives new importance for students to be able to function across differences. The guiding purpose that most consistently informs public education policy is to maintain dominance in the global economy. Perhaps ironically, ethnic studies programs like the ones (now formerly) in Arizona fit squarely within this purpose. Even if one subscribes to the ugly position that there is little value in studying the experiences and perspectives of people who are not White, one cannot refute the point that this area of study will prepare students — including White students — to be better leaders in today and tomorrow’s world.

As a whole, the recent iteration of the ethnic studies debate in Arizona reveals more about the longstanding political-racial ideology of the state than it does about ethnic studies classes themselves. To be clear, this political-racial ideology is one of White supremacy. Unfortunately, like the social toxin that it is, this ideology in practice

via Why Ethnic Studies Courses Are Good for White Kids Too.


5 thoughts on “Ethnic Studies (Participation)

  1. I think the purpose of ethnic studies is to educate any individual regardless of race, gender or ethnicity of the different types of ethnicities. I also feel that the material in the course will challenge some of the more difficult and maybe not so politically correct topics to be brought up and discussed. I feel that many people try to disregard the fact there is such an importance in acknowledging the differences present in races in todays society and I think that ethnic study minded courses are necessary and beneficial in one becoming more aware of the issues of the world around them.
    Some common assumptions that are easy to make about ethnic study courses could include individuals thinking the material is discriminatory towards the white/caucasian races, for some may feel ethnic studies is only putting light on all the different races besides caucasians. Or another assumption that I personally have heard from my peers about this class is that it is all about black power and creates an even bigger gap between the different races, which leads to many people having those feelings of backlash and hate. Some people or groups are so closed minded and refuse to see situations in a new way that this behavior continues to bred selfishness, ignorance and misunderstanding.

  2. The purpose of ethnic studies varies broadly on the spectrum within the field of study. However, in a nutshell as a whole, mainly it is meant to educate non-descriminatory way individuals of other race, enthnicties, and culture of other “races” in our world. Ethnic studies push students to further their own understanding of other individuals, turning them away from sterotyping them or classifying everyone under their race and filling in the blanks with narrow views of that race. These classes help people broaden their horizons to see and understand different individuals in a different light than before. The point is not to warp the views of people to the likings of what a professor, teacher, or instuctor would like but to merely educate to block out the narrow minded views, expanding them.
    Many negative assumptions surround ethnic study courses. People go in with the expecting of idea whites will get slammed for this or that, it tries to build a large sympathy for racial minorities, or that the main focus of the class is clean cut into trying to build up racial minorities of the past or present day. Not the true fact of how the course is there to help people understand how to talk about race and expand their views. That is where the backlash against these courses come into play. People with already strict or narrow views come into the course expecting all the negative perspectives they have heard for the couse. This will do the complete reverse intended effect the course wants because they will leave the course feeling more divided or even more stubborn into their previous views than before. It is almost as if coming in with these views and feeling a rising level of hate throughout the course lets them develop a thing such as, selective hearing or they do not listen due to their own narrow views.This course is not in place to make the gap bigger but to close it and expand the views of people to gain a understanding.

  3. While watching the video i realized that even though in Arizona they already made a law about immigration their are still people in that state who want to get ride of anything that had to do with people of different colors. For me i would have to agree with Tom Horne because he wants students to learn even at a young age what is race and how it affects people all over the world. On the other had their is Gov. Jan Brewer he wants to get ride of Ethnic Study classes. I am still not very sure why he is for it because i believe that everyone should know that whites are not the superior race in the United States. While watching the video i realized that Gov. Brewer was white and wanting to get ride of CES classes and Tom Horne was of color and wants to keep it and wants students to learn. I believe that these types of classes are very important because while growing up in school i was never exposed to these kinds of things and learning it know i just wished i knew more about race. It’s not like i am against it but if i knew more i could have a bigger perspective on life. In a way i also believe that Gov. Brewer is a little bit selfish because he does not want the new generation that is being brought up to learn about race. I just think that he believes that over time will forget about it. -Nohemi Meza

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s